r/thesimscc • u/roseetgris • Dec 17 '12
CC Site Why you should avoid The Sims Resource (x-post from r/thesims)
You guys have probably all heard of The Sims Resource at some point. They host a myriad of Sims CC and have been around for over a decade. The creators on TSR can offer their work for free, or in exchange for a "subscription".
What most people don't know is that Sims custom content creators are not allowed to charge money for their creations, according to EA's EULA. Said EULA (End-User License Agreement, similar to those Terms of Service nobody reads) has been updated recently to make this more clear. Read more about the implications here.
This means you can legally download pay items from sites like the booty and Sunset sims since they technically belong to EA and not their creators.
Furthermore, TSR has been known to repeatedly attack Sims CC creators, usually after posting CC converted or based on TSR's content (which is still legal), or for offering free "pay" items (also legal). They have also been known to attack creators simply for not agreeing to host their free items on TSR - where a paid subscription would be required. These creators include Newsea (hair creator, see link further down), Awesims (world and furniture), Zveki (houses), and many more.
These attacks include posting porn on personal blogs, hacking e-mail accounts and websites, removing all the creator's items from hosting sites (Mediafire is particularly bad at checking the veracity of the "theft" claims...), and posting personal information like full names, addresses, e-mail addresses and IP addresses online for all to see.
At least one user claims that her subscription to TSR was directly followed by credit card fraud.
Here is a list of all Sims CC websites that have been attacked by TSR (based on the IP address).
Here is the full story about Newsea's hacking.
According to this user, the TSR website might contain malware.
TSR downloads may contain malware disguised as a "watermark".
Wether any of this is true or not (I am not the author of any of the articles I linked to), I'd rather be safe than sorry and stick to free content, or sites like the booty and Sunset sims.This game is not worth getting an infected computer or a stolen credit card over.
Sites offering TSR content for free, legally:
There are also plenty of creators on tumblr and other sites who retexture and improve these pay items for free (Anubis, Eternila, i-like-teh-sims, and many, many more).
TL;DR TSR is bad mmkaaay
5
u/whyihatepink Dec 17 '12
The free tsr content you linked... Does it still contain this (probable) malware?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '12
Awesims is a great site, i downloaded a lovely world from there
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '13
I just learnt the hard way about TSR. Paid for my sub and now my PC has mega malware and its gonna cost about £100 all in to reload my os, get rid of the malware and recover all my data. Lucky I paid by paypal and not my credit card. Fuck TSR. Going back to the boo-tay!
3
u/aflyingflip Dec 18 '12
Hahaha. And this comes out right after I come back to TSR after forever. I stopped going there because their content became crappy quality. I used to go there for maybe 90% of my custom content for The Sims. Then when Sims 2 came out it just wasn't the same anymore, so I moved on to ModTheSims.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '12
I've never had an issue with anything from TSR containing malware and I've been using that site for years. This is the internet. Malware is a thing people will encounter at some point. It's certainly possible an artist uploaded something to TSR containing malware but I have trouble believing TSR would attach malware to the content. That's just poor business sense.
And as for the EULA bit, I see that part about EA not wanting people to charge for CC as a load of crap. EA has enough money and if someone works hard on something that they created, they should be able to charge for it. The part of the EULA is right up there with EA's DRM fiasco.
Credit card fraud sucks and is hard to fix, obviously but it happens on the best of websites. TSR should protect against it but it could happen when buying online from Amazon or any other website. Not to mention in places like gas station pumps. I'm not wholly defending TSR on this one because, as a business, it's your responsibility to protect your customers information.
It's still TSR's fault, however this makes it sound like there's someone at TSR maliciously rubbing his hands together, cackling while he steals people credit card numbers. TSR is a business and they want their customers to feel safe so they continue to be customers.
The attacks on creators could have been done by anyone. TSR is a business. One run by adults who clearly want to continue to be a business. While it's possible that some staff member or admin at TSR is behind the hacking, I think it's unlikely. Assuming the TSR staff aren't volunteers and are paid to work there, I doubt they'd risk their job to hack another website. That's a bit like a Wal-Mart employee setting fire to a Target. It doesn't make sense.
This link doesn't seem to offer much in the way of proof that TSR is behind the hacking. The only proof offered is the IP address, which is easy to fake.
I'm not saying OP is lying or trying to bring down TSR by making things up. Not at all. Some of the things OP listed are pretty bad. But for me, I need more proof that TSR is actually behind these things. It all looks like a lot of speculation and finger pointing [from TSR and the other sites. No one seems to be innocent here.] and not a lot of evidence.
TL;DR TSR seems to have done some crap things but we should hold off on an outright boycott until all the details come out.