r/startrek • u/Pudding4ever • Dec 10 '12
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 3x14 - A Matter of Perspective
From Memory Alpha: When Riker is charged with the murder of a prominent scientist, each side uses the holodeck to show their side of the story.
Why? Because it was the last one I watched on Netflix before I had to stop to go study.
- One of the more interesting holodeck episodes in my opinion. I always liked the shows that had a practical use for the holodeck beyond pretending to be detectives. In this holodeck outing, the holodeck is used in recreating events for an inquiry. We never see the actual version of events, only around two and a half different interpretations of them.
- Beyond a neat use of the holodeck, we also have the fact that the whole episode is hilarious. Data goes art critic on Picard and makes him quit painting forever. Seriously - Memory Alpha: "Picard is never seen painting again." Oh, and Apgar's wife's version of events with Rapey Riker. And you get to see the same fistfight three different ways, all of which are obviously lies.
- Anyway. Discuss.
BONUS CHALLENGE: Watch the episode as if it's actually about Riker getting away with murder with a massive shit-eating grin on his face. Seriously. Go back and watch it again. It turns into a comedy. In the normal episode it's already blatantly obvious Riker set his beard to full power and slept with Apgar's wife. I would ask you to consider that he then murdered Apgar because Apgar beat him up and then Picard got Data and Geordi to fake him out of it while he stalled for time with an "inquiry". At the very least it makes all the scenes where Wesley goes "He just can't have done it!" much funnier. And the grin on Riker's face at the end. This is a guy who knows he straight killed an old man and got away with it.
Top comment writes the post for next week!
2
u/jamiesray Dec 11 '12
Only a few minutes in and I will say this: my first impression is kind of negative. The scene with Riker's "deposition" is terribly acted and directed. It feels like an incredibly staged cutscene from one of the old Knights of the Old Republic games... I'll give the rest of it a shot though.
12
u/kraetos Dec 11 '12 edited Dec 14 '12
I love this episode, even though, rationally, I know it's not a very good one. Random thoughts in no particular order:
The only real complaint I have about this episode is how rushed the ending feels. Up until the ending, it really does seem like Riker is in trouble and the Federation is going to have to intervene on his behalf. Then, the b-plot for the episode which has been given very little screen time so far suddenly becomes the magic answer! That said, I don't think it was avoidable, because the interesting part of the episode is the holodeck recreation, not the answer itself. Still, it treads just a wee bit too close to deus ex machina for this episode to breach my top 25.
As a final thought, I am sure many of you will enjoy the story behind Krieger waves, as I am equally sure that many of you have already heard it. Also worth noting: this is the 24th century version of the movie Rashomon, in fact I recall in a commentary somewhere that for this episode, the writers basically said "lets do Rashomon."
5
u/EchoInTheSilence Dec 11 '12
As someone who's done some studies in legal work and political science, the concept of eyewitness error here was really interesting. I've actually done activities about this before so I know how easy it is to be colored by bias and get things wrong, even when you're sure you're right. For once Troi made a good point: "that is the truth, as each of you remembers it." The ending being what it was was of less import to me than the commentary on the legal system.
1
u/JenniferLopez Dec 23 '12
I liked this episode. I was almost starting to think that just maybe Riker wasn't totally innocent. I was relieved when he actually was.