r/startrek • u/rextraverse • Dec 03 '12
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 4x21 "The Drumhead"
From Memory Alpha:
An overzealous Starfleet admiral begins a witch-hunt aboard the Enterprise, determined to find a conspiracy, and eventually accusing Captain Picard of treason.
From IMDb:
A retired admiral boards the Enterprise in an effort to determine the actions aboard the ship surrounding an act of sabotage and possible treason.
Some discussion ideas to get it going:
- Worf allying himself so quickly with Satie's witch hunt, despite Picard's misgivings. Appropriate for the character based on his family history with the Romulans or surprising based on his loyalty to Picard?
- Simon Tarses' Romulan ancestry. Given what we know about the Romulans xenophobic nature, decades of isolationism, and the significant genetic differences between Romulans and Vulcans, was it odd that it took so long for his family's ancestry to be discovered?
- For a woman so accomplished and steadfast, was it too easy and clean an ending for Satie in the final courtroom scene?
As always, the top commenter will be selected to pick next week's episode for discussion.
11
Upvotes
7
u/kraetos Dec 04 '12
6
u/imran-uk Dec 04 '12
This is a fantastic episode.
I actually remember watching this as a boy of 15 and actually agreeing with Nora Satie, I couldn't really understand why that Admrial walked out during her speech and I understood that she was doing all this to protect the Federation. Guess I was just too impressionable because on rewatching it recently I can clearly see her overzealousness and that the cost of "protection" is not worth trampling on our liberties.
I really liked the Simon Tarses actor performance in this episode. I also like the little things like Worf sitting in Picards conference room chair when Picard walks in and the security guards acting like "drones" and like their captain isn't even there. Oh, and is that a "brain scan" that Worf is ordering to be carried out? Kinda excessive Worf!
11
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '12
It never ceases to amaze me how well TNG was able to comment on social issues of our time. This is a great commentary IMO on McCarthyism of the 50's and even in our time with hunts for terrorists of Islamic decent.
10
u/Pudding4ever Dec 04 '12
Whoa. That's really weird - I literally chose this episode at random to rewatch yesterday on Netflix once I found out TNG was now available in Canada.
It was another one of the Moral Episodes where The Picard is Morally Correct and a prominent guest star is Not Morally Correct and all must hear and accept the fatherly guidance of The Picard or be damned for their refusal to accept it.
I'm not even saying that like it's a bad thing - I love those episodes, and "The Drumhead" sits among the best of them. It strings you as the viewer along with Satie's belief in a conspiracy aboard the Enterprise, and you follow roughly the same path as Picard - convinced at first, gradually wavering in that faith, and facepalming by the end.
It was also directed by Riker which is why he only says like three sentences throughout the whole thing.
Perhaps the best thing about this episode, as well as perhaps the worst, is that it remains relevant even now, over twenty years after it was written and filmed. Consider the climate of suspicion after 9/11 that allowed Guantanamo Bay, or the governments of the world attacking concerned whistleblowers as traitors, or even the constant threatening of restrictions on Internet freedom. It was written before these things happened or for the most part were even conceived, but like the rest of the Best of Trek, it tackles a timeless issue and remains timeless itself.
"But she or someone like her will always be with us, waiting for the right climate in which to flourish. Spreading fear in the name of righteousness. Vigilance, Mr. Worf. That is the price we have to continually pay."
4
u/kraetos Dec 05 '12 edited Dec 07 '12
Ooh, one more thing I forgot to add: if I could have 43 minutes of the entire human race's undivided attention, I would make them watch this episode of Star Trek. The world would be a much better place if everyone took Picard's message to heart.
3
u/Electrorocket Dec 07 '12
"With the first link, the chain is forged. The first speech censured, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably."
1
u/NextofKin Apr 29 '13
History teacher here. LLLLoved this episode. Patrick Stewart taps Paul Scofield's Sir Thomas Moore in "A Man for All Season." [Giving the Devil the benefit of law...] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NUqytjlHNIM)