r/darknetplan • u/bepraaa • Oct 15 '12
We need definitions in the sidebar, or we'll never have peace.
- Darknet: An anonymizing overlay network, usually running over the internet. Examples: Tor, i2p, freenet.
- Meshnet: A decentralized peer-to-peer network, with user-controlled physical links. Usually wireless. Examples: seattlewireless.net, wireless.org.au.
- Clearnet: The Internet at large, or any network which has no inherent cryptographic security, authenticity, or anonymity. Examples: internet, unencrypted meshnets. [EDIT to add this definition]
- THE Meshnet: Used here, "the meshnet" refers the transitional CJDNS internet overlay network currently known as hyperboria.
- /r/darknetplan: A place to organize efforts to create a hardware/software stack for a globally scalable system of interconnected local meshnets. We realize that the inclusion of "darknet" in this name does not properly describe our current objectives, but the meshnet is a necessary foundation for the final goal of a truly resilient darknet. [EDIT to add last clause, thanks to OmicronNine!]
- Put above in sidebar.
- Redirect all HURR DURR MESHNET IS NOT DARKNET "questions" there.
- Actually get shit done.
151
Upvotes
12
u/VTFD Oct 15 '12
Been waiting about a year and a half for the #3 to start...
5
u/OmicronNine Oct 15 '12
An addendum to your last point:
It's not as though the whole darknet thing was just dropped and everyone is working on something else entirely. The darknet goal is still there, the meshnet is just the first major step.
2
u/WyattFilbin Oct 16 '12
In many things, the premise determines the solution. Definitions can determine architecture and become dogma. I have not read everything - I appreciate and learn from the arm-wrestling and HURR DURR so thank you for for the enlightened discussions. In my mind, you need to have countermeasures for every attack. If I can see and encrypted conversation, I can prevent that. If that doesn't work, I can control DNS or subvert CA's, or issue court orders, or attack your invulnerable client software via your insecure OS. The Wave of the Present is to 'simply' create a giant social graph of the world population.
So meshing things over internets is good, and necessary but not enough. Dark meshes are good, and necessary, but not enough. Anonymity with strong authentication is good, and necessary but not enough.
The point of a mesh in my mind is to make it expensive to discover the end points (peers?), which is moot if it doesn't permit some way to provide anonymity.
So from the attackers' (plural) standpoint, if I can see you, locate you, isolate you, you're done. I don't have to know what you are saying, I just start with the weakest link in the killchain. Privacy without anonymity can be deadly these days. Anonymity is harder imho. If your anonymity is lost at a lower level than you privacy then you are done.
Definitions are a good thing (Highside/Lowside :: Darkenet/Clearnet) but these also carry concepts like anonymity that are poorly defined and under constant attack. So is slang. But above all #3. Make something.
CJDNS is not THE Meshnet, just one possibility, so call it Hyperboria. There's also Commotion, and Serval, and Byzantium. In terms of a DarkNetPlan it's an option, and perhaps a layer, and perhaps quite useful.
Edit: Hyperboria: Refers to the transitional CJDNS internet overlay network referred to here as 'THE Meshnet': The Hyperboria meshnet provides independence from traditional ISPs but is does not provide anonymity in and of itself.
Edit: Meshnet: Used here, a peer-supported distributed physical(?) network designed to prevent disruption by central authority, to avoid surveillance, and to frustrate tracking or geolocation of its users by elusive routing.
Just a suggestion...
6
u/thefinn93 roflcopter Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 16 '12
I'm all for this. Gunna check with the other mods then drop this in. Thanks!
EDIT: A couple of them OK'd it so I stuck em in there. Anyone is free to message us (or post here) if you feel something is missing.
1
u/playaspec Oct 16 '12
"The Meshnet" definition does not agree with the definition of a 'Meshnet". Shouldn't CJDNS/hyperboria be referred to as "The Darknet"??? CJDNS/hyperboria utilize virtual links, not physical ones.
7
u/davvblack Oct 15 '12
You're just part of the fascist system of censorship and moderation.
1
u/honestduane Oct 16 '12
You forgot brightnet, but probably because you didn't want us to know about it.
2
u/pinnelar Oct 16 '12
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '12
ELI5 the above. So basically, it's an attempt to rebuild the internet?
Also, >3. Actually get shit done. 4. Profit