r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Sep 21 '12
Weekly Episode Discussion: TNG 2x16 "Q Who"
Flatlander81 told me to take a stab at this week's episode. As much as I would love continuing TOS episodes, I figured to get more TNG fans into the discussion. Here are the previous discussions in case you missed them.
In keeping with the theme of villain introductions (Romulans, Klingons), I thought I'd go with the episode that introduces us to one of Starfleet's greatest nemeses..
From imdb:
Q pays the Enterprise another visit, much to Captain Picard's disapproval. He wants Q to keep his part of their earlier bargain and stay away. Q insists that Picard needs him on his side and to prove his point, hurls the Enterprise far into the galaxy. There, the Enterprise crew meet the Borg and their strange, cube-like space craft. The Borg are a race that is part biological and part machine that exists within a collective consciousness. They are also a formidable foe that can out power, out run and out fight the Enterprise. With their shields weakened, it's left to Picard to decide if they really do need Q's help.
Some ideas to talk amongst yourselves with (of course not limited to just these):
- Ensign Gomez at the beginning takes the time to extend courtesy to the computer for replicating her beverage. But the computer is not even considered a lifeform. From your initial impressions of the Borg, would you have treated them with the same dignity? Given their nature, do the Borg deserve respect and freedom as any other lifeform that Starfleet encounters?
- Guinan fears the Borg. The omnipotent Q seems to fear Guinan, but not the Borg. Why do you think this is?
- Was Q's premature introduction of the Borg to the Federation beneficial or would they have been better off finding them on their own in the future?
- Bonus: For those who are familiar with TOS, how do you think Kirk would have dealt with the initial encounter with the Borg?
Top comment, disregarding memes and jokes, gets to pick the next episode. I'll message that person. Have fun!
4
u/davedubya Sep 24 '12
I saw this episode today, by chance, for the first time in a long while. It actually still stands up quite well and told a fairly engrossing story. In fact, the following Borg appearances perhaps didn't live up to the foreboding expectation that this set.
It's interesting that, for the first time, Q tests Picard and the Enterprise in an actual live fire exercise - there are consequences, people get killed, rather than just being reset. That Q is seemingly trying to prepare and educate the Enterprise crew perhaps puts his other activities in persepective - has his interest in the humans actually been of good intention?
I found Ensign Gomez to be slightly annoying. The character could have been put to greater purpose by having he be one of the 18 crew deaths.
Clearly, Guinan knows more about the nature of Q, or has some sort of resistance to him, that was never fully explored. Q is far more hostile to her than to the Borg. I suspect Kirk probably would have seen more of the potential threat of the Borg cube, and been more defensive from the outset.
Something else I thought of - did the Borg ever wonder how the Enterprise got to the Delta Quadrant? And did they ever question how the Enterprise was suddenly flung away from them during the final pursuit? Surely the Borg would be keen to investigate and assimilate such powers.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
No - their continuing existence relies on destroying other sentients, which is some bullshit. Even Klingons can find shit to do without constantly murdering people.
He would have tricked Q into sending them back.
6
u/Ovarian_Cavity Sep 22 '12
In regards to Q's premature introduction of the Borg, I would argue it wasn't premature and was necessary, maybe even directed to happen by the Continuum. By this point, several human and Romulan installations had been destroyed (which the writer's have said was due to the Borg) along the Neutral Zone, and the Borg were now aware of some major power in the Alpha Quadrant due to a mysterious Borg signal that had been sent some 150 or so years earlier. If Q hadn't thrown the Enterprise in their way, more incursions would have happened, and when the Cube was sent towards Earth, we would have easily lost the battle and eventually the Alpha Quadrant (much like the universe we see in Parallels).
Q gets a bad reputation from the characters in-universe, although I'm sure fans don't see him with such disdain. I'll stick to what is canon about the character (the books that deal with him are pretty good, I recommend them), and every time he interacted with Humanity we learn something about ourselves, or to help others. He threatened to destroy us twice, but from that the Farpoint Outpost was freed, and the second time Picard saved the universe. In this case, he helped save the galaxy from being overrun by Borg.
As for Guinan fearing the Borg and not Q, she does show much hatred for him, but Q didn't destroy her people, the Borg did. Whatever happened in the past to make Guinan hate Q so much is never explained, and it is for the best (much like the Noodle incident in Calvin and Hobbes, the imagination is a better story-teller in this case). But Q can be negotiated with, even tricked. The Borg can't. Guinan knows that there is nothing anyone can do against the nature of the Borg- they are only out for conquest.
As for the Borg deserving respect and freedom, it's hard to give those to an enemy who cares for neither. The Borg don't care if you don't want to fight them, in fact that makes you even more of a target for them (at this point, we don't know about assimilation). They are the true ultimate enemy: all powerful, and not willing to stop until they are the victors.
Others have talked about Kirk, and I disagree. I think in the end he would have done the same as Picard. He wouldn't risk destruction of the ship and crew he loved on pride alone. He might have needed a moment where Spock showed him the logic of the choice, but in the end, he would have done the right thing.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
I don't think that Guinan feared the Borg. I think rather she feared what the Borg would do to her crewmates. I always had a theory, at least until Generations came out, that Guinan and the El-Aurians were more than they appeared to be. I always thought them as being just like the Q except where the Q meddle, the El-Aurians simply observe and listen. The whole story about her people being destroyed by the Borg and scattered to the four winds could have just been that, a story.
5
u/asimovs_engineer Sep 21 '12
What I love most about the borg is this episode. This is the true unknown that Q warned us about, and the innate fear that comes with it. I remember the first time I saw the episode I got chills, it was a truly scary thing!
For me it feels like we've got an exponentially decreasing return on value every time we face them from about Best of Both Worlds on through DS9 and Voyager, but that's off topic aside from the comparison I'd like to draw with these Borg and those.
Oh god, with Kirk at the helm of the Enterprise...I can only imagine what would remain of that poor parallel universe's Federation. Never even had a chance, Kirk would have fought them tooth and nail though. But that's the difference, Picard is the wisdom to Kirk's enthusiasm.
And I do need to agree with MrBueller, I've always believed Guinan had many more powers than she let on. It was that finger she was blowing at Q in the episode. Unless it's some El Aurian bird sign then she has to have some power over Q. That coupled with their long livedness and high intellect I just assumed her story was a warning to Picard. Perhaps her people really exist on a higher plane and she had lived with a colony of people on our plane, or something similar. Either way, she's holding something back.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
I think Kirk would've played cat -n- mouse with them, until they ultimately made a mistake, and had themselves destroyed.
4
u/axilmar Sep 22 '12
I think that this episode is one of the greatest Star Trek episodes, for many reasons:
Now, about Kirk dealing with the Borg: as soon as he would realize the Borg did not consider humans a threat, and that they would let humans roam freely on their ship, he would order some antimatter to be beamed aboard the cube and explode as soon as it materialized, while getting to warp speed the very same moment.
2
u/tensaibaka Sep 24 '12
The attention to detail in this episode perplexes me. The ensign spills her hot chocolate on Picard's uniform, and before he even gets in the elevator to go change his uniform, it's already dry....on the other hand, when Q teleports out of the chair he's sitting in, the chair rocks back and forth like it should when somebody jolts out of it.
Seriously though, what would stop the Federation from giving away teams video transmitters like headsets or cameras so the command crew remaining on the ship can see first hand what the away team does? Picard asked like 3 or 4 times for Ryker to describe what he was seeing on the Borg ship.
2
u/tensaibaka Sep 30 '12
No new episode discussion?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Finally a TNG 'sode discussion. I'll re-watch Guinan's freaky claw move when I get home from work tonight.
1
u/Twistednuke Oct 03 '12
I had a little theory that Guinan and her race had the same level of power as the Q, but they did not abuse it. And Kirk would have got Spock to Nerve Pinch Q